Earth Womens Edna

Nice shoe.
It felt and looked like a quality shoe. Leather. The toe was just to round from me. But that was my fault for not noticing.

Too big
The shoe is too big, but it is comfortable

Dk Grey color is SUEDE (never mentioned anywhere)
Purchased one pair for the first time (ivory) and found them to be simple, cute, and comfortable. I wear a 12 on the narrow end of medium width, so hard to find shoes to fit! I went back to see what other colors were available. The dark grey was appealing as an all-season option. Usually, for whatever reason, I have found that burgundy loafers are frequently offered in only patent (not a fan) and grey in suede (also not a fan, especially for spring and summer). I searched everywhere for any mention that the grey were suede. Yay! They arrived today. The grey are simple, cute, and comfortable. AND SUEDE.Come on, Amazon and Earth. If there are differences in shoes in terms of material, LET CUSTOMERS KNOW BEFORE PURCHASE.I am not a happy customer right now.

Oh, I give up!
There’s no consistent sizing. This has got to be the most frustrating shoe shopping experience of my life because they’re such well made shoes but finding a pair that fit is like finding a needle in a haystack. Thank you to everyone who answered my question on how they stretched. Your completely opposite replies on fit coupled with my experience of trying three sizes has convinced me that something has gone wrong with the shoe labelling rather than Earth shoes changing their sizing.I love Earth shoes but haven’t bought a pair for a long while now. In this brand I was always a regular 6.5 and according to the size chart on the brand’s own website this ought still be the case. So this is how my shopping attempt went:6.5: Perfect length, good heel fit, and the most comfortable soles my feet have met with for a long time. The instep was painfully tight. Wearing them at home for 1/2hr an evening over a week did not ease them at all, not even a little.6.5W: Good instep, loose heel, soles too long. I showed them to a friend who’s a regular 7. She said that they looked like normal 7s and asked to try them on. They fit her like Cinderella, so I sent them home with her. Now I have to watch her prancing around in them telling everyone that they’re like walking on clouds….I want to walk on clouds too, darn it! Based on the 6.5Ws having a longer sole for some reason I thought 6Ws might just do the trick….6W: Both shoes: good instep fit, loose heel. Right foot: good sole length fit (as I’d expect a 6.5 from this brand). Left foot: shorter sole (a 6 for this brand), WTH?See what I mean? The sizing is all over the place which makes it all the more galling that the workmanship itself is of a high standard and the leather good quality. It’s a real shame that local stores round my way don’t seem to stock Earth shoes anymore because I’d love to compare shoes of the same size side-by-side without having to play this lucky dip game online.

Absolutely loved this shoe but unfortunately the sizing was way out. I’m a size 7 so I bought a 7 but it was more like an 8. So sent it back and got a refund.